Johnson’s proposed head tax, desired lease tax bad for Chicago employment

Bryce Hill

Senior Director of Fiscal and Economic Analysis

Bryce Hill
November 19, 2026

Johnson’s proposed head tax, desired lease tax bad for Chicago employment

The moves would stand to hurt companies doing business in the city.

Chicago needs jobs and investment downtown. Mayor Brandon Johnson’s proposed budget would discourage what the city needs more of, proposing a business head tax and higher taxes on local tech investment. In a Nov. 10 letter, a majority of the City Council — 28 aldermen — said they would oppose both of those.

Illinois’ state and local sales taxes apply to leases and rentals. This is not unusual in the U.S., but Chicago stands apart by imposing a separate high-rate tax on personal property leased in the city, with the definition stretched to cover software, cloud services and digital automated services.

The city’s personal property lease tax stood at 9% in 2024, rising to 11% in 2025 and 15% this year. The mayor’s budget would increase it to 20%, meaning the rate would more than double across three years. The tax’s expansion to digital services began in 2016, and those services had a lower rate (5.25%) until 2020. Under the mayor’s proposal, the rate on digital services would nearly quadruple from its starting point.

Because this tax includes cloud services, the administration has pitched the increase as a “tax on big tech,” but it’s really a tax on Chicago-based businesses that use cloud services. Businesses use point-of-sale systems, payroll software, accounting systems, videoconferencing, customer databases, reservation platforms, AI tools and a wide range of other digital services every day, at every stage of production. The lease tax applies to those and to business equipment leases and consumer digital subscriptions.

This tax is not paid primarily by out-of-state tech companies. It is paid by Chicago consumers and companies doing business in the city. A business that must operate within city limits — like a retail store — passes much of the tax on to consumers in its prices. Chicago businesses compete regionally and nationally against rivals that don’t pay a surcharge on digital services that the mayor’s budget would raise to 20%. The tax puts them at a significant competitive disadvantage and encourages businesses to hire or expand outside the city.

‘Cloud tax’ follows employees

Because cloud services are sourced to where they are used, the tax follows employees. A company with workers in the city pays more and has reason to ration software licenses for them, hampering their productivity. The mayor presents this as a tax on Silicon Valley. It’s really a tax on every business that employs people in Chicago.

Notably, the mayor’s plan carves out film and television productions, actually cutting their rate from 15% to 11%. The mayor is evidently concerned that no one will film movies in Chicago with a 20% rate on digital services and leased equipment. Yet the budget shows no similar concern for every other business that has invested long-term in Chicago and would face this dramatically higher tax on productivity and local employment.

An even more direct tax on employment is the proposed “Equitable Employer Tax,” $25 per month per employee on companies with more than 125 full-time workers in Chicago. The proposal comes after 29 aldermen established “no head tax” as one of their three conditions for a budget, which must pass by Dec. 31.

Johnson has argued that there’s no evidence the prior head tax was a “job killer,” as former Mayor Rahm Emanuel said when celebrating the 2011 vote to phase out the tax. The evidence suggests otherwise. City employment started declining relative to the suburbs in 1974, when Chicago first imposed a head tax. The divergence flattened out when the liability threshold was raised in 1995 (applying to companies with 50 or more employees, up from 15), and Chicago employment began recovering relative to the suburbs while the tax was being phased out.

Manufacturing losses explain much of Chicago’s overall employment decline in recent decades, but that can’t explain why there were notable inflection points precisely when the head tax was imposed, moderated and repealed.

Head tax hits employment directly

The previous head tax, moreover, was $4 per employee per month before its phaseout, the equivalent of a little more than $6 per month today, adjusted for inflation. The mayor’s proposal is more than four times the inflation-adjusted head tax the city previously repealed as a job killer. It’s a direct tax on employment in the city and tells employers that Chicago wants fewer jobs.

Taken together, the head tax imposes a direct levy on employing people in the city, and the higher lease tax increases the cost of letting those employees do their jobs effectively. There’s a basic principle in tax policy: Whatever you tax, you get less of. The mayor’s proposals suggest Chicago isn’t interested in making the city a more attractive place to hire or retain workers.

Major employers have moved their headquarters outside the city or entirely out of state in recent years. These taxes would only accelerate those departures. The head tax also falls most heavily on the employment of lower-income workers. It’s about 0.85% of a minimum-wage worker’s annual earnings, but 0.15% of a $200,000 salary. To the extent that the tax is passed on as lower wages, it is regressive, as those costs hit lower-income workers hardest. To the extent that employers respond by hiring fewer people, entry-level jobs are most at risk.

The mayor’s proposal includes a tax rebate for employees who work in designated disadvantaged areas, to encourage businesses to locate in those neighborhoods. But the mayor can’t simultaneously argue that businesses will move or shift hiring practices because of the rebate while insisting the tax will have no effect on employment.

Johnson’s budget package includes other tax increases, including higher taxes on liquor and sports betting and a new tax on package deliveries. The package tax falls most heavily on older, less-mobile and lower-income households, which rely on delivery the most. A flat per-package charge, moreover, bears no relationship to the value of what’s delivered, and the tax imposes costs on retailers, especially smaller ones. Exemptions designed to address these regressive elements add significant complexity for a small tax. Only a year ago, the mayor said of a prior package tax proposal that he believed the move would require state approval.

The city needs to close a budget deficit, but the mayor’s proposed tax increases double down on the policies that have brought the city to this point, making Chicago a less attractive place to live and work. Chicago can’t afford to penalize businesses for hiring and expanding in the city.

Want more? Get stories like this delivered straight to your inbox.

Thank you, we'll keep you informed!